Legal Open Data: from Institutions to Crowd-sourcing
Workshop of ICAIL 2013: XIV International Conference on AI and Law
at 10th June 2013 in Rome
Casa Dell’Aviatore, Viale dell Università, 20, Rome, 2.00pm
Program in PDF (47 kb)
Description: The time is ripe for investigating the connections between the representation of legal XML texts and open data paradigms. For years these two communities have pursued their goals separately, but now emerging XML-based standards oriented both to legal documents (Akoma Ntoso, CEN Metalex, national XML standards, etc.) and to datasets (Linked open data, DCAT, etc.) justify the possibility to combine their techniques and foster their concrete application in the society. Several legislative institutions (such as Parliaments, Official Gazettes, etc.) have designed and implemented interesting applications that are among the first examples of crowd-sourced web portals managed by citizens, organizations, movements (e.g. Aaron Swartz’s Law, M5S Italian Movement, OpenParlamento, several private GitHub repositories, etc.). Yet, the legal XML standards are among the necessary technologies for enabling a shared mechanism for lawmaking. The open data approach, when implemented by the deliberative institutions, are instrumental to these activities, at least in order to release the authoritative legal sources as starting points for crowd-sourced annotations, thus improving participation, transparency, cooperation and mediation of different interests coming from the society.
This workshop aims to examine the relationships between Legal XML experiences in deliberative and legislative bodies and the Open Data phenomena, including the horizontal cooperation between institutional organizations and private initiatives through crowd-sourcing.
Questions we will try to address:
* Are the deliberative/legislative bodies ready for Legal Open Data?
* How can Legal XML contribute to Legal Open Data?
* How can crowd-sourcing improve the quality of citizen participation to the lawmaking process?
* Which cooperation is possible between public and private sectors?
* Can GitHub and similar initiatives contribute to drive the political debate?
Welcome from Gherardo Casini, Global Center for ICT in Parliament, UN/DESA
- Global Center for ICT in Parliament, UN/DESA
- 2.15–2.30 Opening remarks:
Monica Palmirani and Fabio Vitali
- 2.30–2.50 Claudio Fabiani, An XML, web based legislative chain at European Parliament, European Parliament
- 2.50–3.10 Carlo Marchetti, Strategies and projects of the Italian Senate based on open standards for fostering transparency, participation, and savings, Senate of Italy
- 3.10–3.30 Elena F. Candia, Working with Linked Open Data, Chamber of Deputies of Italy
- 3.30-4.00 Coffee Break
- 4.00–4.20 Knud Erik Petersen, and Søren Broberg Nielsen, Producing legal information, Danish Parliament and Danish Ministry of Justice
- 4.20–4.40 Davide Barillari, Discovering eDemocracy and in-depth preview of M5S Electronic Parliament (legal aspects), Consigliere Movimento 5 Stelle, Regione Lazio
- Juan Pane, Lorenzino Vaccari: Opening Public Deliberations: Transparency, Privacy, Anonymisation, University of Trento, TrentoRise and Autonomous Province of Trento
- 5.10-5.30 Pompeu Casanovas, Crawling the web: the CAPER Regulatory Model (CRM), IDT, Autonomus University of Barcelona
- 5.30-5.50 Erich Schweighofer, Representation of the Concept Space of Open Data by Thesauri, University of Vienna
May 4th, 2013 May 1oth, 2013
Notification of acceptance/rejection: May 20th, 2013
Registration fee: Check the ICAIL2013 web site for more information
Papers must be original contributions written in English and must be submitted at
as short Papers (8 pages).
Please upload all submissions in LNCS format (http://www.springer.de/comp/lncs/authors.html). To ensure high quality, submitted papers will be carefully peer-reviewed by 3 PC members based on originality, significance, technical soundness, and clarity of exposition.
Publication opportunities: Selected papers will be published in AICOL IV book form in the Springer Lecture Notes in Computer Science (LNCS) series, by March 2014, after a double peer-review process expected for October 2013.
Tom Bruce, Cornell University, Legal Information Institute
Pompeu Casanovas, University Autonoma of Barcelona, IDT
Tom van Engers, Leibniz Center for Law
Enrico Francesconi, ITTIG, CNR
Rinke Hoekstra, VU University Amsterdam/University of Amsterdam
Monica Palmirani, University of Bologna, CIRSFID
Ugo Pagallo, University of Turin
Giovanni Sartor, EUI and University of Bologna, CIRSFID
Fabio Vitali, University of Bologna, Department of Computer Science